Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (2024)

Classic American appetizers like spicy wings and deviled eggs are perfect for everything from game days to midnight snacks. Whether you're looking for a classic appetizer or an updated twist on an old favorite, we've got you covered. From perfect crab cakes to mini mac and cheeses, here are our best all-American bites to start your next meal.

01of 18

Sticky Baked Chicken Wings

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (1)

Chef Matt Jennings means business when it comes to his food and his beloved Patriots football team. For the ultimate game-day snack, he tosses chicken wings that he bakes in the oven (instead of deep-frying) in a spicy glaze he makes with gochujang, the Korean red pepper paste. And best of all, the prepared gochujang sauce can be refrigerated for up to one week.

Get the Recipe

02of 18

Crab Cakes with Horseradish Cream

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (2)

These classic crab cakes are easy to make, as is the tangy horseradish cream.

Get the Recipe

03of 18

Caramelized Onion Dip

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (3)

Take your dip to the next level with heaps of onions slowly caramelized in butter.

Get the Recipe

04of 18

Deviled Eggs With Country Ham

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (4)

Chef Ford Fry's deviled eggs get their terrific flavor from goat cheese, Dijon mustard, and cornichons, plus a topping of country ham.

Get the Recipe

Hogs in a Blanket

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (5)

This fun, high-brow take on pigs in a blanket swaps spicy andouille sausage for the hot dogs, with sweet mustard chutney as a condiment.

Get the Recipe

06of 18

Baked Buffalo Chicken Wings

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (6)

Most of us think of Buffalo wings as bar food, but with their accompaniment of celery sticks and creamy blue-cheese dressing, they make a fine casual meal. These wings are hot, but if you like them incendiary, pass extra Tabasco sauce at the table.

Get the Recipe

07of 18

Fried Pickles with Spicy Mayonnaise

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (7)

Chef Zak Pelaccio grew up eating fried pickles in New York's Brooklyn Heights neighborhood. He coats his extra-crisp version in panko and fries them in schmaltz, or chicken fat, though vegetable oil works well, too.

Get the Recipe

08of 18

Brioche Crab Melts

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (8)

In this delicious version of the classic tuna melt, chef Vitaly Paley pairs moist chunks of crab with brioche, truffle butter, and nutty Gruyère cheese.

Get the Recipe

09of 18

Pimento Cheese & Bacon Crostini

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (9)

Top your toasts with a homemade pimento cheese spread and bacon bits, which get melty and crisp under the broiler in this quick and irresistible crostini recipe.

Get the Recipe

10of 18

Three-Cheese Mini Macs

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (10)

Anything big made small is ultrafun for parties, and these quick, one-bite mac and cheeses are the ultimate example. Cooked in mini muffin pans, the mini macs can be assembled early and baked just as guests arrive.

Get the Recipe

11of 18

Mini Brioche Lobster Rolls

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (11)

These rolls, which are a delightful play on the traditional lobster roll, are quite substantial, so one per person is plenty, especially if you're serving additional hors d'oeuvres. Cooked shrimp or lump crab is a fine alternative to lobster.

Get the Recipe

12of 18

Deviled-Egg Spread

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (12)

"I can't have a party without deviled eggs," says chef Katie Lee, whose cooking often reflects her Southern roots. Here, she deconstructs the retro hors d'oeuvre, blending hard-boiled eggs with mustard and mayonnaise so it's more like an egg salad that she can spread on toasts.

Get the Recipe

13of 18

Pigs in a Blanket with Black Pepper Pastry

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (13)

Jen Pelka, co-founder and CEO of Une Femme Wines, loves serving Champagne with playful bite-size foods like pigs in a blanket. To take them up a notch, she brushes the puff pastry with a tasty mix of honey, mustard, and fresh black pepper before rolling up with the hot dogs and baking.

Get the Recipe

14of 18

Baked Chicken Wings

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (14)

These supereasy baked chicken wings use just a few ingredients and four simple steps.

Get the Recipe

15of 18

Bacon-Wrapped Cherry Peppers

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (15)

These genius hors d'oeuvres from 2005 F&W Best New Chef Colby Garrelts call for just three ingredients. The recipe can be made ahead of time, so it's great for parties.

Get the Recipe

16of 18

Cast-Iron Cornmeal Cake with Buttermilk Cream

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (16)

Pouring the batter into a hot skillet ensures a perfectly cooked, dark golden–bottomed crust with a fluffy, golden interior. Serve this slightly sweet cornmeal cake warm, with a big dollop of buttermilk cream.

Get the Recipe

17of 18

Caramelized Five-Onion Dip

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (17)

A mix of five different alliums — shallots, scallions, and sweet, yellow, and red onions — upgrades this classic caramelized onion dip with layers of flavor. Serve it with chips, toasted bread, or vegetables like endive, steamed fingerling potatoes, and roasted broccolini.

Get the Recipe

18of 18

Deviled Eggs with Pickled Shrimp

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (18)

To amp up his creamy dill-and-chive deviled eggs, chef Bobby Flay tops them with tangy pickled shrimp.

Get the Recipe

Our Favorite All-American Menu Starters (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Nicola Considine CPA

Last Updated:

Views: 5428

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (69 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Nicola Considine CPA

Birthday: 1993-02-26

Address: 3809 Clinton Inlet, East Aleisha, UT 46318-2392

Phone: +2681424145499

Job: Government Technician

Hobby: Calligraphy, Lego building, Worldbuilding, Shooting, Bird watching, Shopping, Cooking

Introduction: My name is Nicola Considine CPA, I am a determined, witty, powerful, brainy, open, smiling, proud person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.